Comparison of Injection Molding and 3D printing

Some people have difficulty to choose a right process for his plastic part project. Injection molding or 3D printing?

Here are some advantages and disadvantages of molding and 3D printing:

Advantages of molding:
High production volumes: Once a mold is created, it can be used to produce a large number of identical objects quickly and efficiently.
Consistency and accuracy: Molds can produce objects with high accuracy and consistency, ensuring that each object is virtually identical to the others.
Surface quanity: Molding process can turn out very smooth surface, even mirror polished surface.

Materail: There is wide range of material available for molding -- ABS, PP, PE, PC, PS, PA, PMMA,PET, TPE/TPU, engineering resins......

Large object sizes: Molding is better suited for producing large objects, whereas 3D printing has limitations on the size of the object that can be produced.
Cost-effective for large volumes: Molding can be a more cost-effective method for producing large volumes of objects, as the cost per unit decreases as the volume increases.
Disadvantages of molding:
High setup cost: The initial cost of creating a mold can be expensive, particularly if a custom mold is required.
Limited design flexibility: Molding is less flexible when it comes to design changes, as any changes to the mold may require significant time and expense.
Lead time: Molds can take time to create, which can delay production.

Advantages of 3D printing:

Design flexibility: 3D printing allows for a high level of design flexibility, making it ideal for producing customized objects.
Rapid prototyping: 3D printing allows for the quick and inexpensive production of prototypes, which can help speed up the product development process.
Low setup cost: 3D printing does not require expensive molds or tooling, making it a more cost-effective method for producing small volumes or one-off objects.
Ability to produce complex geometries: 3D printing can produce objects with complex shapes and geometries that would be difficult or impossible to produce with molding.
Disadvantages of 3D printing:
Limited production volume: 3D printing is generally slower than molding, making it less efficient for producing large volumes of objects.
Limited material option: 3D printing is currently limited in the types of materials that can be used, although this is rapidly changing with advancements in technology.
Lower accuracy and surface finish: 3D printing may not be able to achieve the same level of accuracy and surface finish as molding, particularly for larger objects.
Higher cost per unit for larger volumes: 3D printing can be more expensive than molding for large volumes of objects due to the slower production speeds.
Overall, both molding and 3D printing have their advantages and disadvantages, and the choice of manufacturing method will depend on factors such as production volume, design complexity, and cost considerations.

Get instant quotes right away